Friday, March 31, 2023

Postblogging Technology, December 1952, I: What A Laugh It Would Have Been




R_.C_.,
Arcadia,
Santa Clara,
California.

Dear Father:

I'm told that, some day, I will look back very fondly at long college vacations and having grandparents at my beck and call when the little darling(s) get to be too much. Well, these must be the golden days. We arrived in Chicago on Friday by train, with a beaming Grandpa and Grandma and a silent and stoic driver (and distant cousin on Mother's side) waiting with hugs and kisses for James. Well, not George. That would have been strange. (Prodigal daughter held her tongue and guiltily carried her handbag at least.) Grandma is . . . 

You know what? I am going to leave that sentence, and that thought, behind me. After all, I am calling her "Grandma" now precisely so that I don't slip back into that cold and slithering "Mother" of my teenage days. Chicago is exactly as cold and snowy and windy as I remember, but so what? We're off to get a Christmas tree in an hour and there is a crackling fire in my room and my robe is fleecy and thick. Probably because, like that Warm House scientist says, individual fires make homes colder on net, but I am sure that that is some kind of average across the hallway and the spare room across, and I'm not there, I'm here! All that's missing is Reggie, and he will be  here on Thursday. 

We'll be doing some entertaining later where I will possibly have to be polite to people I don't want to be polite to, but actually to be fair to my parents they've been very careful in their invitations over the weekend, so none of the fabled Ronnie freeze to go with the Lakeshore wind!

If there are at this late date any qualms about Christmas presents for James, I very briefly mentioned some of the wonderful new "industrial toys" out this Christmas. Doepke has a wonderful set, which I haven't succumbed to the temptation to collect because I didn't want to spend my entire allowance and deprive anyone else of the chance to do the same. 



Your Loving Daughter,
Ronnie



Flight, 5 December 1952

Leaders

"Encouragement to Fly" I'd make a joke about hats, because I started making those jokes so I wouldn't have to talk about these silly bits about air force reserves and privileges and subsidies, but you might think I wasn't dealing with a Leading Article seriously enough. And you'd be right! I'm not!

"Weighty Considerations" And I'm not the only one. C. T. Wilkins, the lead designer of the Comet, recently pointed out that a single pound of weight saving on the Comet was worth £55 on a passenger flight, £38 as freight. Which is why BOAC should recruit very small people, especially dwarf stewards. I feel as though Flight is leading me gently around a terrible accident scene disguised as the obvious (and horrible) joke about fat stewardesses. 

"Hydro-Skis" After a long and, I assume, well-paid career designing not very much of anything successfully, Henry Knowler gives this year's Bleriot lecture on the subject of, of course, "The Future of the Flying Boat." BECAUSE IT HAS ONE DON'T LISTEN TO ALL THE CRITICS NO NOT HIM OR HER EITHER OR THOSE PEOPLE OVER THERE LISTEN TO ME LOOK AT ME I AM TALKING TO YOU GIVE ME MONEY! And then something about how the latest iterations of high performance floats will work for sure. To be fair, the outgoing Assistant Air Secretary of the Navy said something nice about the Convair flying boat fighter, and the Navy has been hornswoggled into the new Martin jet flying boat bomber, so the whole flim-flam show has at least another ten years of life in it, but that doesn't mean that serious people have to pay attention.

"The First Avro-Built Canberra" Not that anyone will care by next week, unless Avro somehow sells the plane to the new German Air Force, but they have delivered the first of its contracted Canberras, engines to follow at some future date.

From All Quarters reports that the first four Meteors have been delivered to Denmark. If you're wondering why they would want them, they're the Armstrong-Whitworth night fighter variant that is less obviously obsolete. British West Indian Airways has ordered four Viscounts, a second Western Hemisphere order after Trans Canada's fifteen. The Secretary of State for Air observes that it is £4 cheaper to fly a serviceman to the Middle East than to ship him. ("Her," too, I bet! Or, no, maybe servicewomen aren't allowed to be plump, which would make for an even larger saving.) This ties in with the Chief of the Air Staff's recent musings about how just four modern, four-engined, high speed jets could carry more troops to the Middle East than "the latest troopships." A calculation based on a fleet of Bristol Britannias suggests the scale of costs, but the transports envisioned are variants of the Valiant and "a Handley-Page." A Valiant transport might be able to carry 150 troops at 40--45,000ft from England to Egypt in about 4 hours. The Handley-Page has similar figures and is attached to a cost estimate of £7 per man. It seems hard to believe that the charter airlines would go along with this without a fight.  

The Pathfinders have had a Ball and the Oxford University Air Squadron has had an annual dinner. A select lot of Air Marshals popped into both and some of them gave speeches about how nice it is that all the top-hat nobs and "It" boys realise that it is an air age, and commiserate with them that the Yanks get to fly Sabres around town while they are stuck with Harvards. Hawkers apprentices also had their annual dinner, but with no toffs invited. Maurice Prevost has died, and Auster wants us to know that they have a salesman over in Japan. 

Here and There MiG-15 claims in Korea have surpassed 500. Belgium has ordered "a substantial quantity" of the Percival Pembroke that (sorry about spoiling the end!) will be cancelled next week. A USAF sergeant has been accused of spying for North Korea. A new and presumably more powerful Sapphire, the a.s.7a, is reported. Army Chief of Staff Lawton Collins says that the Army will procure 2000 helicopters and light aircraft for transport "within combat zones." Cargo helicopters big enough to lift 155mm howitzers short distances, such as across rivers, are envisioned. India is going to license-build Vampires, while Australia is turning 51 Mustangs over to South Korea. 

Aircraft Intelligence reports that Rolls Royce seems to be operating a Griffon-powered prototype Frith helicopter, that the A3D has just made its first test flight, that various US fighters are getting new canopies similar to the one on the Republic XF-91, that the F-84F will not have wing root intakes, but will have air brakes, that the CF100 Mark 4 has just had its first test flight, that there is progress on the Max Holste 1521 Broussard, Matra Cantineau helicopter, Fauvel Av.36 glider, and the Breguet Super Deux-Ponts, which might eventually have Wright Turbocompound engines. 
"The Battle of the Bangs, Round 4: A New Foray from the House of the Hunter" The controversy over the cause of the loud "bangs" being heard from supersonic aircraft continues. The current contribution is from J.W. Fozzard, a senior mathematician at Hawker, with further comment from B. A. Hunn. As far as I can tell, the conventional wisdom that it is caused by breaking the sound barrier, is at least roughly right. 

"PEDANTICA," "Defence Exercises and Reality" Intercepting bombers is all very well, but, and hold on your hats, it seems like the bomber will always get through! But say that you had a "monitoring missile," developed from the modern radiation-detector, that could fly through a bomber formation and identify he ones with atomic bombs? Then you might actually be able to stop the atom bombers, in spite of what seems like the magnificent ineffectuality of the Air Exercise interception battles. And what about V-2s? Stopping them seems to call for holding Denmark and Germany, which are full of yucky Continentals. I know! Clearly the solution is giant airship radar stations to give advanced warning of enemy bombers so that they can be shot down by "ramjet-guided missiles" with a range of more than fifty miles! And then bombers will fire missiles at the missiles, and that will mean fighters to fire missiles at the missiles that are fired at the missiles, and everyone searching for the control frequency to take over enemy missiles, and where will it all END?  

"The Teacher's Dilemma" The Daily Mail says that there aren't enough advanced science teachers because they aren't being paid enough, which is why there are 273 unfilled science teacher positions in the United Kingdom right now, and one-fifth of science teachers are underqualified. 

Our American Correspondent reports that due to the election there was practically no aviation news last fall, and notes that in at least one case this was deliberate, with the re-opening of Newark Airport strategically delayed until after the election, and news of its very expensive ($9 million) runway, necessary so that aircraft will no longer fly over populated neighbourhoods, was drowned out by Eisenhower being nice to McCarthy and Truman being mean to Eisenhower. Also, there are new regulations on air carriers, mainly for noise reduction, and talk of technical measures, too, because otherwise it is quite possible that all the New York-area airports were going to be closed. The Super-Constellation has had its first test flight, with 63 ordered. There are also 50 DC-7s now on order. It is advertised as cruising at 350mph TAS with turbocompounds, carrying 65 first class or 95 tourist passengers, with an 84lb/sq in wing loading, and requiring a 6400ft runway. These aircraft have been ordered, in spite of their near-certain obsolescence within five years (of service entry, I guess is meant) because tourist-class traffic keeps increasing in the United States. The Canadair CL-21 looks like it might be the next "can't fail" DC-3 replacement to fail and drive its manufacturer out of the airliner business. (OAC even utters the fatal words, "few efficient aircraft fail." BECAUSE THERE ARE FAILED "EFFICIENT" DC-3 REPLACEMENTS LITTERED ON THE RUNWAY IN FRONT OF YOU, YOU MORON!

The RAeS has heard a nice talk about the latest Blackburn wind tunnel weight balancers, and Geoffrey De Havilland has won this year's Guggenheim medal for the Comet.

"Stratofortress" Flight has a nice technical article on the B-52. It is somewhat speculative, since Boeing has not discussed the aerodynamics of the plane yet. The issue is that Boeing has gone with what has worked for them in the past, a long and heavily loaded wing structure of "extreme flexibility," which makes control very difficult, especially as the engines spread the load a very long distance from the fuselage. The ailerons can't be too far out, because of wing twisting, and can't be too far in. So there are probably some new departures in control theory at work on the plane, and Flight  takes a guess at what they might be. (A short article about the new Piaggio trainer follows.)

J. Vivian, "Are Flight Dispatchers Necessary?" Some people are saying that they aren't, that the aircraft captain is basically enough, but Vivian doesn't think so. 

Flight really liked episode 3 of Victory at Sea. "Occurrence of High Rates of Ice Accretion on Aircraft" is out in the Professional Notes of the Meteorological Office of the Air Ministry.

Correspondence

Years ago, before and during the war, correspondent Philip Moyes flew a meteorological version of the Halifax, which he thinks everyone has forgotten. John Grierson had some experiences flying jets that he thinks that The Sound Barrier ignores or sensationalises, and someone has let Geoffrey Dorman have writing implements again, so please stop that. 

(Nobs fly too!)


"At the Royal Institution" The lads heard a nice letter from C. T. Wilkins on the Comet, presumably where the "No fatties!" Leader came from. It is mainly to the effect that strict weight control was needed to make the Comet practical, and led to decisions in other areas, such as the long, thin, heavily-loaded wing, the lack of further sweepback, and constrained design around the engine outlets to reduce vibration. Even then, the load factor is low for an airliner. 

Civil Aviation has  bits about the ICAO forming a technical aid department to help some countries that might need it, continuing progress in reducing tourist rates, a rise in chartered flights this month, and a report that the De Havilland Rapide crash at London Airport on 1 September was caused by turbulence from a passing Stratocruiser. The Ministry of Civil Aviation has put up 11 Solent flying boats for sale at an asking price of £35,000, no reasonable offer refused, down from a purchase price of £150,000. Tourist flights are up 42% for BOAC's Atlantic services. The first Comet being built for Air France is ready for test flights. Brazil has ordered four Convair 340s. 

The Industry reports that the Dowty "magnetic eye" indicator has found a new use, testing fire detection circuits on aircraft. New Wellbeck's cleaning machines are specially suited for cleaning aircraft cabins. Miniature Bearings, Ltd., has a new issue of its memorandum, RMB Communications Two, out, full of details on miniature bearings, some of which have their own lubricant reservoirs while others are "air" bearings. North American has been putting them in guided missile gyros. Bells Asbestos and Engineering has large, flexible ducting for heating and cooling planes. The BEAMA Catalogue is great for keeping up with the British electrical industry, while British Standards has Electric Cables for Aircraft (glass and polychloroprene insulated) describing three authorised types, single-core copper, aluminum-core, and twin and multi-cores. 

Service Aviation has interesting notices about HMS Glory going off for its third tour off Korea and the RAAF squadron which has been providing transportation services in Malaya for three years finally rotating home after replacement by an RAF Valetta squadron. 
 



The Economist, 6 December 1952

Leaders

"The Claws of the Dove" The Economist is as disgusted by the Prague purge trial as everyone else, particularly noticing their anti-Semitic character. But then it goes on to denounce the Vienna Peace Conference as basically the same thing, which seems ridiculous to me! The basic idea is that all those intellectuals and artists and leftists are bad for wanting peace because wanting peace will lead to a worldwide Communist takeover, and you can tell that Communists want to take over the world because they are running a disgusting show trial in Prague.

"Cortisone for Politics" Cortisone shots are good for arthritis, and the British political system is arthritic, so The Economist is happy to hear about reforms like proportional representation that might happen. 

"Neguib Against the Odds" General Naguib looks like he is at the end of his rope, and maybe he is, so maybe all the investor countries like France and Belgium should help, along with Britain and America. I'm not sure how? The Economist burbles for a minute about how Egypt needs better civil servants, but you'd have to have a hole in your head to think that Belgium could send over a batch of incorruptible and efficient civil servants to run Egypt better than the Egyptians! 

"'Gas and Water' Telephones" The Economist is appalled and disgusted that some British towns run their own telephone exchanges, because telephones aren't like gas and water. Hull seems to show the contrary, since its rates are cheaper than the Post Office (which otherwise runs the telephones in Britain), but The Economist detects signs that it is "living on its capital," which obviously has to stop.

Notes of the Week

"Opposition by Procedure" The Churchill government can't control the House of Commons and the Prime Minister is losing his mind, but somehow it is the Labour Party's fault that the house has been in chaos all week. Meanwhile, Bevan is having a hard time fitting in. The UN debate over the latest Indian Korean armistice proposal didn't go anywhere, the Russians are obviously wrong when they say that the Geneva Convention says that the Red POWs have to be repatriated, but the Americans didn't do a good job of making that case. The British participants were great, though! 

"Templer Reports" The situation in Malaya is improving, but we shouldn't let down our guard, because they are trying to infiltrate all the left wing organisations and continue the struggle politically. Meanwhile there is not a similar situation developing in Kenya, and anyone who says that it is, is just making trouble! Although if they keep on complaining they will probably encourage a mass Kenyan rebellion into being, so they should shut up and meditate on the fact that the old Labour government was just as much in favour of capitalism and development and European settlement as the Tories. In the Saar, the fact that the major parties took 88% of the "valid votes cast." The issue, not very clearly explained is that a blank ballot was being pushed as a way of supporting German nationalist parties which had been banned from the polls. The fact that only 24% of ballots were turned in blank, as against the 40% expected, shows that Saarlanders are just fine with being occupied by the French and everyone else should now shut up and be okay with it, which I doubt is true, and doubt even more will happen! A more plausible interpretation is that the ballot is seen as strengthening Adenauer against the nationalists, and given a choice, actual German voters have no time for the nationalists. 

"Conscription and Commitments" If you were wondering what the dust up in Parliament was that The Economist didn't feel like it could talk about explicitly before launching into explaining how it was all really Labour's fault for doing its job, it was that Shinwell has proposed reducing National Service to eighteen months, and the Prime Minister, in effect, called him a pinko traitor. The Economist points out that the army is already struggling with being down 15,000 men, and reducing the conscription period by six months would increase that by 50,000 men and make it impossible to ship them off to Kenya and Malaya, while trooping, which already costs £30 million, will be even more expensive! Also, it will somehow encourage European allies who have agreed to hold conscription at eighteen months, to cut below that because of the British example! Shinwell is being terrible and also irresponsible in another way, because he might alert the public to how unfairly large the British share of "western defence" is (because obviously Kenya and Malaya are part of "western defence") and lead to the public demanding cuts, and that would be bad because who would shoot all those Communists and Mau-Maus then? I'm convinced! Did you know that the French don't send conscripts overseas at all? Labour isn't fighting the Government over the Town and Country Planning Act, although the Labour left would like to; Communists aren't trading for Western consumer goods, which shows that Communism is on the rise (I don't think it shows that at all!). German exporters are getting more competitive, especially in Europe, but are cheating because they aren't running a big military production programme and so have capital goods to spare. Everyone is reminding the Germans about the camps because of the current Nazi  resurgence, including Germans. The National Dock Labour Board has come up with a scheme to encourage dockers to find work outside the industry because it looks like the slump is going to be "prolonged." Civil Defence is having trouble finding volunteers and hospitals aren't very financially efficient. The Economist thinks that if America wants to host the Uno, it can damn well be polite about its assorted attempted anti-communist purges in the Uno staff! The Pope has brought the College of Cardinals up to strength by appointing 24 members, including some anti-Communists, some kind-of-okay-with-Communists and even one progressive. The Irish Central Bank issued a report about how the Irish government is mismanaging the economy in the middle of the Irish budget debates. The Economist is pretty happy about it. Something should be done about the Press being so irresponsible that doesn't interfere with freedom of the press in any way. 

The Economist of 1852 runs a review of Thackeray's Henry Esmond. I'm really tempted to go down to the library to pull out the volume and see if this was the biggest story of December, 1852. Thanks to years of this feature I know James Wilson like a brother, and he is perfectly capable of putting out an issue with nothing worth writing about except a book review. And it is December (Christmas presents!) and it is Thackeray. So maybe? The Economist of 1852 really didn't like it very much. 

Letters

The world lets The Economist have it with both bores this week. Hugh Gaitskell takes on The Economist on convertibility, R. F. Kahn sarcastically explains why dear money is incompatible with capital investment, R. I. Gray asks how all the ERF dollars have been poured down the hole of Australian high-cost industrial development when Australia isn't even taking up as many dollars as before the war, and is building up a new sterling surplus. Joel Bernstein doubts that the American economy is as incapable of soaking up more imports as people say when the trends are pushed back before the war. The terms of trade are against the American consumer, he says. J. R. Sargent and P. Kuhn defend the EPU and the Benelux agreement. 

Books

Well! If saying dumb things about economics is going to generate that kind of controversy, let's get on with it with a review of the British Economy, 1945--1950 that explains why Oxford University economics professors are so dumb! (Mainly they don't realise that because Britain has to trade with the rest of the world, everything is impossible and everyone is doomed, as the interwar period goes to show, shut up everyone who thinks that things were going fine until the Korean War.) Hugh Seton-Watson's Decline of Imperial Russia gets a review, and so does Maurice Buckmaster's Specially Employed: The Story of British Aid to French Patriots of the Resistance, both are very much in the vein of "this is not the book I would have written" with not much more constructive to say than that. Well, of course, you say, they are a  history and the memoirs of a spymaster, respectively, and don't go to the magazine's expertise like its double review of Spiegel on The Development of Economic Thought and Suranyi-Unger on Comparative Economic Systems. Well, bad news on that front! (They're also too long because decadent Americans don't ration paper.) So that leaves us with Dymia Hsiung's Flowering Exile: An Autobiographical Excursion, which title doesn't give me a lot of confidence. I think most of us have encountered people given to autobiographical excursion, but only because there aren't warning buoys to steer us clear. Well, here's one with a title! And I think the review probably puts a bow on this week's section by being the first positive one. 

American Survey

"Economic Horizon" During the election, Eisenhower promised to stop inflation, and the Democrats promised to prevent a depression. Well, which is which? Inflation or deflation? Deflation, of course, due to the end of the Korean War buildup leading to a reduction in government spending of some 450 billion. Will this lead to a recession, The Economist really wants to say "no," but can't quite get there, so it spends a page and a half going in circles, instead. 

"Segregation in Schools" The Economist can't say that desegregating primary and secondary schools is an unnecessary fuss since everything is getting better in every way (ever more Coloureds can read; the universities are desegregating okay), and why rock the boat? But it can imply it! 

American Notes 

"Full up in the Cabinet" Various people are complaining about who Eisenhower did or didn't put in the Cabinet, with the new Labour Secretary in particular being seen as a thumb in the eye for Taftites. Also, Henry Cabot Lodge is going to the UN and not the cabinet, and another story covers how Americans might be taking the McCarran Committee's investigation of alleged American communists at the UN more seriously now that there's a grand jury in New York going over the same ground. Because of the famed impartiality of grand juries, you see. (The Economist will have a great American office someday when they've actually lived in America for a while.)

"Wilting Controls" The Eisenhower Administration is committed to getting rid of controls, and they're going ,but that doesn't mean that we can't have another article about the twilight of the planned economy, and in particular the difficulty the Democrats are having in handing over a still-intact system of controls for Eisenhower to dismantle. (So that the GOP takes all the blame.)

"Trustbusters in Competition" Two major antitrust investigations, the one into American oil companies abroad, and a new one into Du Pont's alleged effective control over GM and the American Rubber Company, are said to have originated as hot potatoes to drop in Dewey's lap in '48, and are now hot potatoes for Eisenhower. The Economist hopes that the oil company investigation will be dropped for reasons so obvious that they do not need explaining; but expects the Dupont/GM one to go on, because Eisenhower has put so many auto company men into the Cabinet and taken so much money from the industry that dropping it would look bad. Fortunately, The Economist goes on, with the FTC now under a Republican appointee, this antitrust nightmare will soon be over. Or, at least, less annoying!
 

"Foundations on the Carpet" The House Committee on the non-profit foundations which corporations have been allowed to set up to take up to 5% of their profits as tax write-offs since 1935, has failed to find the expected nests of anti-American ultra-liberal communists at the Rockefeller and Guggenheim foundations, and in fact committee council Brook Hayes thinks that the committee has done excellent work in showing how good these foundations have been for democracy. The Economist thinks that they could do with a bit more scrutiny in case some corporations have decided that charity begins at home. 

A huge new steel mill on the Delaware may be close to tidewater, but might also be too much capacity for the current market. Senator Morse will vote with the Republicans on the reorganisation of the Senate on 3 January so that the GOP will carry the can for the three days before the inauguration, too. 

The World Overseas

Rhodesian tobacco doesn't cost dollars
"Berlin Outpost" Stop me if you've heard this one, but it turns out that there is an enclave on the west side of the city of Berlin controlled by the Western powers. These days, it is much nicer than the Communist-controlled parts, and this has become quite the issue for Communists, we imagine. They are probably about to launch a grand campaign of subversion against the Western sector, or they already  have, our Special Correspondent isn't quite sure. Anyway, Berlin is a very nice city! Please approve this entertainment expense voucher. Oh, by the way, East-West trade is declining rapidly, mainly because the amount of timber and wheat the Soviet Union can ship is declining. The next Uno budget will be smaller and the Uno will probably get less glamorous, although the  Latin American countries hope not. Italian politics are quite byzantine and sound very amusing when you try to summarise them in four paragraphs because Father Sturzo has done something.  Which leads to another story about how Italian Catholic politicians are becoming more confident and assertive! The Czech purge trials have become a political issue in Israel, where the Mapam party, which is dependent on Arab votes, has been pushed into (sort of) supporting the official Czech position, leading Ben Gurion to believe that it can make gains against the right by positioning itself against international anti-Semitism. The Economist's correspondent really likes Rhodesia, which seems much nicer than South Africa. Our Correspondent then proceeds to describe a racist country with strict segregation combined with anti-immigration policies against British and South African immigrants, rampant anti-immigrant bigotry, low wages, hard lives, a housing shortage, and a sentimental attachment to forced labour to prevent "the blacks" from going south to Johannesburg for higher wages. But no "moral decay," so that's good!

The Business World

"Prospects for the Gold Price" Increasing the price of gold would inject desperately needed liquidity into international trade, but Americans don't want to buy all the gold it would summon from the ground at a higher price. As long as world trade is so weighted towards America, the Commonwealth prime ministers can be expected to propose a higher gold price, and Americans to reject it. 

"How Thrive the Armourers?" The Royal Commission investigating the state of the Royal Ordnance Factories has some views. For one thing, it looks like the idea that Woolwich is a white elephant and needs to be substantially whittled down, is taking hold. For another, even the ordnance plants in other parts of the country are relatively inefficient. Did you know that there are, on average, 1 Service inspector for every 4.3 employees? This is in large part because the Navy insists on having its onw, separate inspectorate, it seems. Anyway, there are 50,000 employees working in the ROFs, mainly at the engineering plants, since we have enough ammunition, and they don't make the complicated weapons, so what exact good are they? Besides the two plants that make tanks, that is. 

Business Notes

The Commonwealth Ministers' meeting continues as an endless debate over whether Australia but also Canada and New Zealand should produce more commodities to earn more American dollars, or more capital goods to replace American capital goods paid for with dollars. Also, they'd like to get more dollars for their gold, while Britain now thinks it will have enough gold to cover the extraordinary payments that will be needed in December. In other "the crisis has gone away in the new data" news, production figures have recovered. credit is expanding, the London stock market is generally up (although "paused" this week. Also up, bonusses, wool, the Rank Organisation, rubber, Barclays. Coffee prices will be up with the end of the Ministry's mass buying scheme. Airlines are competing vigorously in the tourist market, especially now BOAC and the Irish. The Economist went to a machine tool trade show and was impressed with plain (toothless) bandsaws, and the "electrodeposition" technique, in which grinding wheels and work pieces are charged oppositely, causing electrostatic discharges between the two that increase the rate of grinding. Pakistan is imposing controls on imports after failing to sell a good part of last year's cotton and jute crops. The Egyptian government has closed the Alexandra Cotton Exchange and will sell cotton for itself. International control of cobalt supplies will end. Harold Wilson's Development Councils for industry will be dissolved because industry resented their membership fees and weren't cooperating.


Flight, 12 December 1952

Leaders

"Elastic Programme" Flight has pretty much the same things to say about the "stretch-out" of the defence programme as The Economist, and since I have done the issues in reverse order, I am going to make you wait. Flight is a bit more upset that we are still worrying about "the nation's pockets" than The Economist, though!

"Progressing in Strides" It used to be said that British aircraft designers were doomed by their failure to keep up during the war, but that hasn't happened due to some excellent interim or stretch designs. Now, the "four-jet medium bombers" promise a shining new future! Although it will probably involve selecting a smaller number of designs earlier in the process, and producing them on multiple production lines to keep up adequate delivery rates, even at the expense of more tooling costs. 

"The Canberras Home Again" Remember when those Canberras left on a South American goodwill tour? Now they're back! 

From All Quarters reports that the RAF is getting ready for the Coronation Fly-Past, and that Duncan Sandys' comments explaining the "stretch-out" statement on Defence Production indicates redundancies and layoffs of about 2500 in the 200,000 strong aeronautical industry due to cancellations of Meteors, Vampires, Venoms, Pembrokes, Balliols, Varsities and Canberras. Glosters will be particularly affected until Javelin production begins. Vampire Trainers and NF11s are not affected. The Vulcan is not on the super-priority list, although its production is coming along well, but some of the civil types for the New Zealand Race will probably get super-priority. Speaking of which, the rules for the race blocks and handicapping are now out. The Royal Aeronautical Society  has heard two papers on helicopter ground testing, and there have been other aviation events in southeast England this week in spite of the fog. 

"Gas-Turbine Lubrication: A New Synthetic Oil Developed in This Country" Esso's Turbo Oil 35 gets a full page advertorial. What is this? Aviation Week? J. C. Gibbings has given a lecture on Aerodynamics of Wind Tunnel Design at the National Aeronautical Establishment in Bedford. 

Here and There reports that William Littlewood of American Airlines will give this year's Wright Lecture. Crop spraying companies are now spraying drying agents on wheat and barley prior to harvest. The spate of F-89 crashes was caused by a structural weakness in their wings. Eric Mensforth, the Vice-Chairman of Westland and President of the Helicopter Association, urges municipalities to stake out helicopter ports as quickly as possible before they run out. Dornier Aircraft is coming back into the aircraft industry. J. H. Kindelberger says that a practical intercontinental ballistic missile is just over the horizon. Derby Town Council is protesting the BEA's decision to built a power plant within a mile of the perimeter of Derby Airport, as the 425ft chimney would be a hazard to air navigation. 

Aircraft Intelligence reports that the Avro Vulcan will have a ribbon braking parachute, which is an improvement on solid chutes as currently used. The second production Viscount is now flying. A Hercules-powered Blackburn Beverley is now undergoing Certificate of Airworthiness trials, while London and Rhodesian Mining has bought De Havilland's London-based Beaver demonstrator. The
Unfortunately, testing revealed a hitherto unknown hydrodynamic phenomena known as "waves"

Convair XF27 is expected to "fly in the near future." The latest model of the Neptune, the Lockheed P2V-6, is intended mainly for mine-laying and ASW and differs from previous aircraft mainly in "convertibility features" and avionics. It has a smaller radome and "highly fire resistant" stainless steel engine nacelles for its turbocompound engines. France is developing the Nord 3100 transport from the Nord 2500, while the latest Italian advanced trainer is the Macchi B. 323. 

An historical article on the FE2 series of bombers from the Royal Aircraft Factory that served in WWI, by J. M. Bruce, follows. "Older readers" have been enjoying these articles, so here's a longer one with more pictures! Which is fun and good for circulation, but not what we're here for. 


"Aid to Approach" Flight reproduces an example of the new MCA instrument-approach charts, and then it is off to visit "The Indonesian Air Force" with Hugo Hooftman. 

"Test House Silencing: Methods Employed on the Olympic Test-beds at Bristol" British people are a bunch of sissies about noise, so Bristol decided to do a little something about it, because, ridiculous as it seems, people were upset that they could hear them "several miles away." Basically, they put a bunch of mufflers, some on shutters, around the test bed. The text of Mr. Churchill's statement on defence expenditure, and the leading questions from the Opposition, follow. The only new thing in them (at least, once you're done with The Economist) is that the Prime Minister evaded a question from Arthur Henderson on the effect of the cuts on the front-line strength of the RAF at the end of the programme. 

"Jet Transports: US Ideals" The Air Transport Association of America has published Design Recommendations for Turbine Powered Aircraft. It wants 70-80 passenger capacity in four-abreast seating, 11 cubic feet of cargo space per passenger, 5500ft runways (at sea level) for 2000 mile flights, 7200ft for 3200. There should be air conditioning, costs and avionics should be comparable to existing types, aerodynamics should be acceptable, especially in terms of limited climb rate for passenger comfort, so no rocket-like climbs to operating altitude or dives from it, to save fuel!


Civil Aviation News reports that the Comet 3 will be externally similar to the existing Comet but will have a 20,000lb payload allowing up to 78 passengers in tourist class. Your old company will be doing the Pakistan air survey, as I'm sure you've heard. The Air Registration Board has removed its ban on the Tudor, and government machines are available for purchase at £10,000, less than the projected £15,000 required to give it a proper freight door. BEA is chartering some of its Ambassadors to fly royals around. Air India is offering tourist rates while Central African Airways is cutting costs. The 13 July 1952 Proctor accident near Rochester Airport, Kent, was caused by either pilot error or fuel starvation. American Airlines is the first to ever make more than £1  million in a month from air freight alone. IATA has recommendations on runway lighting, ICAO is still arguing about the international phonetic alphabet for radio, V. A. M. Hunt gave a talk on "Air Traffic Control Today and Tomorrow" to the Royal Aeronautical Society this week. He mainly focussed on radar, which is a real help on less well-controlled air routes and will be necessary when turbine aircraft come into heavy use, as visual checks of separation distance will not be enough. He also talked about efforts to increase landing rates at congested airports. The last direct passenger service between Canada and Australia has come to an end with the scrapping of the ship involved, so the airlines had better step it  up! After-season bookings for Atlantic flights are unexpectedly high as business executives switch from liners and tourists take advantage of off-season rates. Floyd Odlum says that Convair could have a 200 seat airliner version of the XB-60 in the air by 1955 if someone would just pay for it! 

Air Marshal Sir Richard Saundby has given an address on "The Air Battle" to the RUSI, which, from the summary, sounds to be in the "years ago, before the war" genre, beginning in 1914 and reaching the Battle of Germany at the bottom of the third column, spending two paragraphs on it before it is off to Japan, and the conclusion that air superiority is good. Questions such as, "Can I go to the bar now?" were then fielded. 


Correspondence

So, anyway, years ago before the war, the Brisfit was quite the thing and the Koolhoven "BAT" might or might not have existed. After we get through that, there's a boring letter about actually relevant things from A. W. Selwyn, Assistant Secretary (Technical) of the OUAS. Lord Hives says that they are not getting adequately trained men from the schools. Assistant Secretary Selwyn points out that it isn't possible to train them when all the good engineers and scientists are going to industry instead of the schools and universities, and maybe he should stop complaining about the quality of university men until he has put his money where his mouth is and endowed some chairs. 

The Industry reports that Lord Aberconway told the Westland annual general meeting that the company has a £10 million order book, that the Whirlwind is distinguishing itself in Korea, and that the problems with the Wyvern are almost sorted and that it would go to the fleet soon. The associated company, Normalair, is doing fine, too. Petbow of Kent has some nice generators for runway and hangar use. 


The Economist, 13 December 1952 

Leaders

"Atlantic Alliance" The meeting of the ministers next month occurs against a background of general optimism about good results, but also fears about the future and the prospect of a fun little food fight between Germany and France over German rearmament within the European Defence Community on the one hand, and the French trying to get out of their obligations by citing Indo-China, which is completely different from the British supporting Western defence by sending troops to Malaya. 

"Defence: Enough?" Although this is a thing that the awful Aneurin Bevan used to say, now, it is Churchill saying it, and he's great! But confused. So let's parse the story. It turns out that "the defence programme . . . has succeeded sooner, and at lower cost, than anyone had seriously dared to hope." The original £4.7 million programme has changed over the last two years as research and development has continued. And, yes, actual defence production increases less in the second and third year of the programme than was intended. And, yes, the Government decided to level off procurement in 1953 rather than further increasing it, as planned. That will mean spending £600 million less than planned. But, thanks to American progress in atomics, and new aircraft, and guided missiles, we don't need all that stuff. Also, it turns out that we can't afford to produce all those weapons and still maintain engineering exports. But! If the reason for throttling back defence was financial, then Bevan was right! "No one need be ashamed of agreeing with Aneurin Bevan now." (Even though he was wrong in detail!) It is, however, important to remember that he was right for the wrong reasons. Bevan was afraid that the programme would endanger peace. If Churchill can reduce the programme now, it can't have failed, so it must have maintained the peace! And since the Korean War might end soon, that's obviously true. Also, we're not really ending the programme so much as stretching it out. 

Meanwhile, Labour is being very rude in the Commons. It is almost like they do not want to let a Government with a very small majority rule like it has a very large one. Meanwhile, everything seems to be going well in Denmark, so that's nice!

Notes of the Week

President Eisenhower wants less war in Korea, General MacArthur keeps saying more war, and the new Secretary of State seems to expect WWIII. Nobody knows anything! WWIII or not, the Americans better get behind Britain over Abadan, or the communists are sure to take over in Iran, and, more importantly, London will fall down on the carpet and hold its breath until it turns blue. General Neguib is going to have a referendum on the future of the Egyptian monarchy, and Labour is due for to stare into its own bellybutton for a season or two over whether there is some connection about Bevan's return to the front benches and all the procedural wrangling with which they have been slowing the Commons. Rents might be allowed to go up in Britain if and where they can be proven to pay for necessary repairs as the British rebuild their housing stock. 

"Kenya's Land" Kenya's problems are apparently related to "overpopulation, land hunger, low wages, poor health, and so on," and not the fact that Kikuyu leader Jomo Kenyatta is about to go on trial on suspicion of Mau Mau activities and the Kikuyu population is radiating silent anger over it, which is making it hard to promote anti-Mau Mau forces. You see, the crucial point is that Kikuyu resentment can't be relieved by just giving them land, because they are bad farmers, and not because the current distribution of land reflects "existing obligations incurred . . . in relation to the security of land reserved for the different races." Which seems to mean that the Kikuyu can't be given land in the Highlands, because that is for white people. 

At this point I thought I would point out that, according to my Funk and Wagnalls, Kenya has a total land area of 224,961 more than twice that of the United Kingdom, and a population of 6 million, less than a seventh! While in North Africa there has been rioting in Casablanca and a political murder in Tunis leading to a French crackdown on Tunisian nationalists while leaving French settlers alone. The French continue to insist that these things are only happening because foreigners pay attention to them. Maybe the fact that the French aren't doing as badly in UN voting over Tunisia shows that the world agrees with them? The horribleness of the UN is shown by the fact that the Indonesians and Guatemalans are pushing a resolution condemning British land policy in Tanganyika even though they aren't spotless themselves. And in Venezuela they cancelled the election in mid-count and the army took over the government, which absolutely isn't a coup d'etat! The Economist is sad and disappointed with everyone, up to, and including the average Venezuelan for possibly voting wrong. 

The trade  unions aren't actively sabotaging "denationalisation," but it is deemed that they could be doing a better job of supporting it. It turns out that the cotton industry slump in Lancashire was quite "comfortable" compared with prewar, and that is due to the welfare state, which, on balance, might be a good thing. The National Foundation for Education Research has studied intelligence tests, which were supposed to give an objective measure of a student's potential, and discovered that, in fact, scores are affected by coaching, practice, and variations in teaching. The Foundation recommends that at least two examinations and an English composition test be used to choose the schools students are sent to so that suitable students get to go to grammar school and unsuitable ones don't. Dr. Malan is throwing a bunch of politicians into jail because what's the point of just oppressing the Coloureds? Europe is  having another economic conference; The Capricorn Society of Southern Rhodesia has come out with a "Declaration" of racial policy for the new Federation (and Kenya.) It is basically just apartheid, but it is sincere and comes from the liberal side, so it is probably as good as you can expect, just "a generation too late!" People object to saying "cold war," but they are wrong. Hungary's government is worried that the population is getting restive due to the drought. There's an argument on about the rules for pedestrian crosswalks in Britain. The Economist is upset with the Waverley Scheme, which does not assign enough money to buying British artworks that would  otherwise be exported. 

The Economist of 1852 is on about "Fiscal Half-Measures." A letter from "An Old Subscriber and a Steady Reader" complains that cutting the malt duty in half won't make any difference at retail, and keeps the whole, objectionable burden on business, so all it accomplishes is a loss of revenue. 

Books

E. L. Hargreaves and M. M. Gowing have Civil Industry and Trade, which seems to be a volume in the official history of the British economy in WWII, although the reviewer doesn't mention it, instead launching into the explanation that it is actually a history of the Board of Trade in WWII, because it was in charge of industrial controls, so it is actually the history of Industrial Controls. It turns out that they work as long as people think that they are fair. J. D. Mackie has The Earlier Tudors, which is a disappointing and old-fashioned history. and also bad because it is "planned," as opposed to "private industry" history. I guess it is one of those Oxford historical series? It's still a silly way to end a review. I think! Roger Dehem's L'Efficacite sociale du systeme economique is a book about the welfare state, but in French! The Economist is a very sophisticated reader, so of course it keeps up with the conversation in French. So what does this French man say, when he is not eating garlic on frog's legs? It is very confusing and French. Just to show what a broad minded reader we are, we go on to R. M. Hare, The Language of Morals, which sounds quite interesting, although not quite as much  in the way of turning problems in philosophy into problems in language that appeal to me. (It's very much the thing in France these days for those too young and fashionable to fall for existentialism!) A. Silley's The Bechuanaland Protectorate is a history of the colonial government the British were forced to set up because they couldn't stop Cecil Rhodes any other way. (Ronnie rolls her eyes.) Nina Epton's The Oasis Kingdom: The Libyan Story, is a cheerful traveller's tale that fills a Libya-sized gap. Or Tripolitana, anyway. 

Letters

J. W. Hatch explains why The Economist's proposed "Atlantic Payments Union" is idiotic. C. J. Stewart has his own ideas for constitutional reform. Roy Lewis and Angus Maude defend the bank employee wage figures they used in their book. J. H. Ray of the British Trawler's Federation explains the Federation's problems with Icelandic fishing restrictions. "A Greek" has concerns about some arcane corporate finances, L. Murray Stewart and "An Actuary" have opinions about insurance and pensions. John G. Walker thinks that cities have no place subsidising operas and symphonies if they can't make money on their own.

American Survey 

"Korea at First Hand" President Eisenhower went to Korea to see what he could see. Americans were very relieved that he didn't die. (I wasn't! I never understood that fuss at all. President Roosevelt flew to Teheran in the middle of a war!) Then he relieved everyone even more by sending out a very moderate press release. He's not going to bomb more, he's certainly not going to bomb China, he is going to continue to increase Republic of Korea troops as quickly as he can, and he is not taking the offer of Koumintang troops that the GOP (but not Chiang) keep presenting him with. For one thing, it says here diplomatically, Koumintang troops aren't battle-ready yet. For another, it would just restart the Civil War. 

"Shopping Goes Suburban" There are shops in the suburbs now that everyone is going out to live there. It says so right here, so it must be true!

American Notes

"Labour Under New Management" The presidents of the CIO and AFL have died within a short time of each other, They're still upset at the Truman Administration, mainly for the unfairly large settlement with the UFW, and are feeling out more unification. Government is too big these days but the GOP probably can't reverse the trend. Business is doing its best not to break out in a chorus of demands for tariff protection, so as not to embarrass the new Administration. A post-mortem of the last election shows that existing spending limits on campaigns are unrealistic. The price of meat is too high, Alger Hiss has refused probation because he won't admit that he is guilty, 95% of American bank accounts are covered by Federal deposit insurance, and Senator Wiley has launched a boycott of "Red" Christmas ornaments being imported from eastern Europe to put $75 million in "Communist coffers." 

The World Overseas

"Dollars for Defence Industries" The Economist explains that "offshore procurement," in which America pays for European guns from European factories, is "Europe's third chance" to overcome its chronic dollar deficit. Will it work? The first two chances did nothing to reform industrial structure or the terms of trade. This one could, by building up European capital goods industries and allowing them to compete around the world more efficiently, later. Two articles cover the peace treaty ratification debates in the German Parliament, which have had many twists and turns, including for some reason straying into the territory of German reluctance to pay for defence. There is also a discussion of France, where Premier Pinay is "becalmed" in spite of winning the confidence vote on his new budget, because his tax reforms are so controversial. Of them, the most interesting and perhaps important is a sort-of value-added tax on all sales, which could finally get at the subterranean streams of the economy that have so frustrated the French tax collector over the years. We'll see how that goes! He is also promising a reduction in spending in Indo China thanks to the new Viet Namese army and American aid.

"Revolution in Chinese Villages" The Batchworth Press has a book on Chinese land reform based on Chinese official statistics. It does not sound like it is going well, except for the cadres, who seem to be following the trail to prosperity blazed by the Soviet bureaucracy. Pakistan seems to have weathered the financial crisis brought on by the failure to sell the jute and cotton crops. The World Peace Conference in Vienna turns out to be Communistic and not pacific, and also a bit dispirited because of the Slansky trials. 

The Business World

"Industry and Defence" British expenditures on defence are probably running at £1600 million this year and not the budgeted £1462 million, more than half of that from pay, feeding, housing and other personnel costs. Expenditure on defence equipment next year will be about £600 million. This year, it has included £203 million for aircraft and stores for the RAF; £156 million for guns and ammunition for the Army; and £238 million for shipbuilding, with clothes at another £66 million. To hold spending at £600 million next year means cuts this year, or spending would have to rise to £825 million next year. Although the Army's spending has been the most restrained, eyes have to be on the three factories producing Centurion tanks, which seems like more production than demand can possibly require. Some recent sales to Canada and Nato might keep the factories operating, but otherwise something must be done. Cancellations of outstanding orders of Vampires, Meteors and some Venoms is no surprise to the industry, but The Economist is being a bit disingenuous when it lumps the Canberra cuts in with them and suggest that they are not needed now because the medium bombers have suddenly shown up out of the blue. Although it is probably correct to say that Britain doesn't need four production lines of Canberras. The Percival Pembroke is cancelled outright, and Derwent production will be wound down, while Sapphire production is delayed. To maintain full employment and make use of capital investment, the aviation industry will have to sell abroad. Hopefully the Americans will buy a bunch of British planes for the Dutch and so on, but it is not guaranteed. As for the electronics industry, which employs almost as many as the aircraft industry, they really  have nothing else on their plate and things will have to be seriously redirected, possibly even sending their raw materials to consumer producers. 


"Can Cinemas Pay?" Arthur Rank says that since a third of the earnings of British cinemas in 1950--1 came from ice cream sales at the cinema, movies don't actually pay and after going round and round the numbers for a while, The Economist agrees with Rank that the Entertainment Duty  (which subsidises exhibitors) has to come down. 

Business Notes

The proposal for a Finance Corporation for Industry to support development in the Commonwealth gets the lead Note because it comes straight from the desk of the publisher's nephew, I guess. Commodity prices are "improving." Japan might be a new and dangerous competitor in textiles, but now there's a chance to play with Japanese bonds, and who can pass that up? Exports are down in November on preliminary data. Steel output is hitting its 16.1 million ton target. Coal consumption is finally cutting into stocks again. Although the reason for that is cold weather, The Economist is wiggling like a puppy over the chance to run another "Coal Doom!" Note. The last Utility scheme, in furniture, is over. The recent flood of soap suds on the River Lea is probably a bad thing! Probably something should be done!


Wool textile workers are going back to work, shop sales are up, the swap of 15,000 Brazilian cotton for 70 Meteor jets will probably go ahead if the Brazilians can guarantee good cotton. The Brazilians would like to sell mixed cotton, which might be acceptable if we don't end up with bad cotton. The price of Persian lambskin is up, French sterling holdings have been unblocked, zinc is off control, trends in manpower are for labour to shift out of textiles, although the growth in engineering manpower slowed in the last two months of the year. 



Business Reports wonders if it is time to call the turn to recession. Yes, business profits are up, but so are inventories, and farm income is down, presaging lower consumer demand. Capital outlays are falling, the machine tool backlog is "melting." Eisenhower weather might be chilly weather. 

Products and Processes
has many interesting items. 

Fortune has advice for the Eisenhower Administration: i) Don't cut taxes to pre-Korean War , like the Republican chair of the Ways and Means Committee urges. Reform the income tax, let the Excess Profits Tax expire, enhance the current prosperity without letting inflation take hold. Don't listen to silly people who say that the electorate voted wrong. Don't listen to the New York Stock Exchange, which only represents itself; or business executives who think that labour has nothing to complain about when they could just buy stocks. (Which are often out of reach of the working man's pocket.) Also, Corliss Lamont is terrible, not least because Fortune is going to miss The Daily Compass. Communism is terrible, especially the Czech kind. Corporations should give more money to colleges, and probably will, with tax changes. That story about how the next two months are the "stabiliser's last stand" again. 

"Business After the Defence Boom" There's probably going to be a recession, Fortune repeats for roughly the millionth time. It sure looks like there will be!
The problem is mainly falling defence spending, but it does not look as though other parts of the economy can make up for the loss of defence spending. Industrial capacity is built up, consumers are stuffed with stuff, savings are falling (relatively), cars are too expensive these days, there's no place for new homes, customers are worried about the future, and population growth is falling. Business needs to innovate, might want to think about getting into electrical generation, and stick with consumer durables, which will probably hold steady on the spending side, at least. It will probably be a "middling" recession.

It's no wonder the baby boom has dropped through the memory hole if it wasn't noticed when it was happening!
An article about how Westinghouse has just got its new lease on life, follows. If you're wondering why that is, part of it is that the company has launched a $251 million expansion plan to get its share in expected increases in American generating capacity. The other part is that the guy who launched the expansion is a new chairman named Gwilym Alexander Pierce, which is somehow a real name, and Fortune feels the need to give him a bit of a puffing up. We're reminded that they're building an atomic-powered generating station and that they might branch out of turbine engines to turbogenerators.

There's the obligatory story on the art of selling, and then a look at the recording industry, which is doing its best to keep up with the demand for classical recordings, and is making heavy use of magnetic tape recording to produce new recordings in a timely way. A large part of the reason that a recording of Stravinsky's Fifth that would have gone for $12 in 1939, will go for $6 today, is that pieces can be spliced together from tape instead of requiring repeated individual recordings. Also, the covers of record albums are very nice these days. And speaking of unexpectedly beautiful things, a piece on the new industrial toys that are not news to the mother of a two-year-old-boy, but might be to a proud grandfather. There really are some beautiful toy bulldozers out there these days!



"The Instrument Frontier" looks at the helium refrigerator, mass spectrometer, ultracentrifuge, helium cryostat and x-ray diffraction. Did you know that x-ray diffraction might be taking pictures of the structure of  molecules soon? Linus Pauling of CIT thinks we're on the verge of understanding even the big protein molecules. John Rust is the king of cotton picking machines. 

Ronson is in trouble from cheap Japanese imports, and Fred Musser is the biggest Christmas tree grower of all, and Fortune asks whether head office should follow all the houses and the shopping to the suburbs. Probably!



No comments:

Post a Comment